Summary Investigation Information

Investigation Number: 337-TA-1185

Investigation Type: Violation

Docket Number: 3418

Investigation Status: Terminated

Title (In the Matter of Certain):

Smart HVAC Systems, and Components Thereof

People IconProcedural History

Complaint Filed 10/22/2019


Date of Institution 11/27/2019


Markman Hearing Dates

Start

End


Evidentiary Hearing Dates

Scheduled Start 11/16/2020

Scheduled End 11/19/2020

Actual Start 11/16/2020

Actual End 11/19/2020


Target Date 08/20/2021


Final ID On Violation

Due Date 04/20/2021

Issue Date 04/20/2021


Non Final (Terminating) ID Issued


Final Determination of
No Violation
07/20/2021


Final Determination of Violation


Termination Date 07/20/2021

 

Unfair Act Alleged+

Type Active - Inactive
Patent Infringement 11/22/2019 -
 

Patent Number(s) +

Number Active - Inactive
10,018,371 11/22/2019 - 07/20/2021
8,131,497 11/22/2019 - 07/20/2021
8,432,322 11/22/2019 - 07/20/2021
8,498,753 11/22/2019 - 12/15/2020

HTS Number(s) +

Number Category Basket
90321000 Consumer electronics products
90322000 Consumer electronics products
90328960 Consumer electronics products
 

People Icon Participant Information

- Active
- Inactive
Complainant Information

Name - City/State/Country Lead Counsel for Service Active Inactive Date
EcoFactor, Inc. - Palo Alto , CA , United States
Russ August & Kabat 11/22/2019 -

- Active
- Inactive
Respondent Information

+ Name - City/State/Country Lead Counsel for Service Active Inactive Date
+
Alarm.com Holdings, Inc. - Tysons , VA , United States
Foster, Murphy, Altman & Nickel, PC 10/22/2019 -
Disposition, Date Disposition by Unfair Acts, Date Remedial Orders Issued, Issue Date, Status, Change Date
No Violation Found 07/20/2021
Customs Enforcement Desc Forum Receipt Customs Letter Seizure Forfeiture Order Documents
+
Alarm.com Incorporated - Tysons , VA , United States
Foster, Murphy, Altman & Nickel, PC 11/22/2019 -
Disposition, Date Disposition by Unfair Acts, Date Remedial Orders Issued, Issue Date, Status, Change Date
No Violation Found 07/20/2021
Customs Enforcement Desc Forum Receipt Customs Letter Seizure Forfeiture Order Documents
+
Daikin America, Inc. - Orangeburg , NY , United States
Latham & Watkins LLP 11/22/2019 - 07/01/2020
Disposition, Date Disposition by Unfair Acts, Date Remedial Orders Issued, Issue Date, Status, Change Date
Settlement 07/01/2020 Patent Infringement 07/01/2020 07/01/2020
Customs Enforcement Desc Forum Receipt Customs Letter Seizure Forfeiture Order Documents
+
Daikin Industries, Ltd. - Osaka , , Japan
Latham & Watkins LLP 11/22/2019 - 07/01/2020
Disposition, Date Disposition by Unfair Acts, Date Remedial Orders Issued, Issue Date, Status, Change Date
Settlement 07/01/2020 Patent Infringement 07/01/2020 07/01/2020
Customs Enforcement Desc Forum Receipt Customs Letter Seizure Forfeiture Order Documents
+
Daikin North America LLC - Houston , TX , United States
Latham & Watkins LLP 11/22/2019 - 07/01/2020
Disposition, Date Disposition by Unfair Acts, Date Remedial Orders Issued, Issue Date, Status, Change Date
Settlement 07/01/2020 Patent Infringement 07/01/2020 07/01/2020
Customs Enforcement Desc Forum Receipt Customs Letter Seizure Forfeiture Order Documents
+
Ecobee Ltd. - Toronto , , Canada
VENABLE LLP 11/22/2019 -
Disposition, Date Disposition by Unfair Acts, Date Remedial Orders Issued, Issue Date, Status, Change Date
No Violation Found 07/20/2021
Customs Enforcement Desc Forum Receipt Customs Letter Seizure Forfeiture Order Documents
+
Ecobee, Inc. - Toronto , , Canada
VENABLE LLP 11/22/2019 -
Disposition, Date Disposition by Unfair Acts, Date Remedial Orders Issued, Issue Date, Status, Change Date
No Violation Found 07/20/2021
Customs Enforcement Desc Forum Receipt Customs Letter Seizure Forfeiture Order Documents
+
Google LLC - Mountain View , CA , United States
WHITE & CASE LLP 11/22/2019 -
Disposition, Date Disposition by Unfair Acts, Date Remedial Orders Issued, Issue Date, Status, Change Date
No Violation Found 07/20/2021
Customs Enforcement Desc Forum Receipt Customs Letter Seizure Forfeiture Order Documents
+
Schneider Electric SE - Rueil-Malmaison , , France
Jenner & Block LLP 11/22/2019 - 08/31/2020
Disposition, Date Disposition by Unfair Acts, Date Remedial Orders Issued, Issue Date, Status, Change Date
Settlement 08/31/2020 Patent Infringement 08/31/2020
Customs Enforcement Desc Forum Receipt Customs Letter Seizure Forfeiture Order Documents
+
Schneider Electric USA, Inc. - Andover , MA , United States
Jenner & Block LLP 11/22/2019 - 08/31/2020
Disposition, Date Disposition by Unfair Acts, Date Remedial Orders Issued, Issue Date, Status, Change Date
Settlement 08/31/2020 Patent Infringement 08/31/2020
Customs Enforcement Desc Forum Receipt Customs Letter Seizure Forfeiture Order Documents
+
Vivant, Inc. - Provo , UT , United States
Williams Simons & Landis PLLC 11/22/2019 -
Disposition, Date Disposition by Unfair Acts, Date Remedial Orders Issued, Issue Date, Status, Change Date
No Violation Found 07/20/2021
Customs Enforcement Desc Forum Receipt Customs Letter Seizure Forfeiture Order Documents

People Icon Agency Participant Information

Office of Unfair Import Investigations (OUII)

Level of Participation: Full


Name
Jeffrey Hsu
Paul Gennari

General Counsel (GC)

Name
Houda Morad
Michael Liberman
Megan Valentine

Administrative Law Judge (ALJ)

Name
David Shaw

- Active
- Inactive